What Happened in Kremenchuk
This message (material) was created and (or) distributed by a distant media outlet acting as a distant agent and (or) a Russian legal entity acting as a distant agent.
As a result of a missile attack by Russian troops on a shopping mall in Kremenchuk (Poltava region of Ukraine), a minimum of twenty civilians were killed, and dozens of area units missing. Kyiv is referred to as the incident-associated act of coercion and a “deliberate attack on a civilian facility.” Russian officers 1st same that this was “a new Ukrainian provocation within the sort of Bucha”, and so during a message from the Russian Defense Ministry they admitted that they were battery Kremenchuk. However, consistent with the Russian military department, as a result of the strike “on a warehouse of foreign ammunition at the Kremenchuk plant of road vehicles and their ensuant detonation, a non-functioning shopping mall was broken.” Meduza explains why the Russian Defense Ministry’s explanations look false.
Around 4 p.m. on June 27, a strong explosion occurred within the center of Kremenchuk, and virtually 10 seconds later, a second. At an equivalent time, a powerful fireplace bust gets into the native Amstor shopping mall. among many hours, it burned to the bottom.
According to town authorities within the evening of an equivalent day, nineteen bodies were found at the positioning of the hearth, and one amongst the wounded died in the hospital. regarding forty a lot of folks were in all probability within the shopping mall – and haven’t been connected since then. quite fifty folks came to the doctors with numerous injuries, largely burns.
The Ukrainian Ministry of Internal Affairs reportable that the strike was allotted by X-22 missiles (read below regarding what reasonably missiles) from Tu-22 bombers that took removed from the Shaikovka field within the Kaluga region.
Later, the Kremenchuk authorities showed journalists an enormous crater and a destroyed workshop at a road machinery plant settled next to Amstor (known within the countries of the previous USSR because the manufacturer of the Kredmash asphalt paver). The funnel is found regarding 0.5 a metric linear unit from the shopping mall. Its terrible presence and placement appear to substantiate the version of the Russian Ministry of Defense, that expressed that it had smitten a blow at the plant wherever the ammunition was stored: they allegedly detonated and set the fireplace to the shopping mall throughout the explosion. However, actually, this is often not the case.
We will instantly justify why the version of the Ministry of Defense of Russia doesn’t last
First, the “non-functioning searching center”, contrary to the assertion of the Russian Ministry of Defense, truly worked: this is often what it gave the look of 2 days before the missile attack. Moreover, it clothed that many days before the strike on Kremenchuk, the house owners of the middle ordered to not evacuate guests associated with store workers throughout an air attack (which happens often there; the Ukrainian prosecutor’s workplace has already secured to ascertain the actions of the Amstor administration).
Secondly, the mall was hit by another explosion, not the one that caused the crater at Kredmash.
Thirdly, the sequence of events was essentially the opposite: the explosion close to the shopping mall (which, apparently, LED to the hearth in Amstor) occurred 10 seconds before the explosion within the manufactory look. judgment by Google maps, there are not any hangars directly at the positioning of the explosion close to the shopping mall, wherever ammunition, that the Russian Ministry of Defense talks regarding, might on paper be kept.
Now let’s take a better cross-check of what these claims area units supported.
On June 28, many videos from police investigation cameras from the town park of Kremenchuk, which is found right behind the fence of Kredmash, appeared: the plant is found precisely within the middle between the park and Amstor. judgment by the videos, folks, and birds on the pool within the park were afraid of one thing – in all probability a foreign explosion; and ten seconds later there was a brand new explosion – and extremely shut.
Having determined the placement of the objects recorded on the video, it is often established that the epicenter of the second explosion was within the workshop of the Kredmash plant. it’s not possible to seek out the epicenter of the primary explosion from the footage – but, in one of the videos, you’ll see however somewhere behind the plant (approximately wherever the shopping mall is located), even before the second explosion thundered, a column of thick smoke rises.
In addition, Meduza obtained pictures taken on the day of the attack on Kremenchuk from a hill 3 kilometers from the plant and Amstor. The resident of Kremenchuk World Health Organization sent the photographs (as he claims) and asked not solely to publish his name, but conjointly the photos themselves. supported them, you’ll decide wherever he lives; commercial enterprise such pictures might threaten Meduza’s supply with criminal liability in the state. it had been uphill to substantiate the version of the origin of the cinematography by Meduza; at an equivalent time, we have a tendency to couldn’t sight signs of forgery.
The photograph shows 2 explosions similar in power; in one, the smoke within the higher a part of the “mushroom” had already begun to dissipate, and from that it is often finished that it occurred a bit earlier. Meduza geolocated the cinematography location, in addition, because of the approximate location of the explosions. the primary one (where the smoke began to dissipate) happened close to the Amstor searching center; the second – was on the territory of the plant “Kredmash”.
A series of photos (which, judging by the modification in mushroom clouds from explosions, were taken in succession for tens of minutes) don’t show any traces of the secondary detonation of ammunition (which were, for instance, in Kyiv in March 2022 when a missile attack on the Retroville shopping mall, wherever Ukrainian the military hid artillery and shells). The smoke from the explosions simply keeps dissipating; additionally, it’s clear that a fireplace starts within the shopping mall space.
It is attainable to see specifically wherever the rocket exploded close to Amstor by examining satellite pictures from the Gregorian calendar month and June twenty-eight, 2022. The June ones show not solely destruction within the shopping mall, but also, presumably, a crater from a rocket explosion – right next to the single-track railway separating the territory of the shopping mall and therefore the plant. The possible location of the missile hit could be a few tens of meters from the wall of the shopping mall, behind that the cozy store was set. it had been during this store, as follows from the stories of workers of the shopping mall, that there have been most of the dead and missing. forthwith when the explosion, a fireplace raged there. A video of the rocket’s arrival from police investigation cameras appeared, confirming the situation (the coordinates are viewed here).
On the idea of this knowledge, it is with confidence declared that the primary rocket exploded within the immediate neighborhood of Amstor, and therefore the other exploded within the search of the Kredmash plant. it’s conjointly possible that there was no “munitions detonation”, which, in keeping with the Russian Ministry of Defense, diode to a fireplace within the shopping mall (at least twenty-four hours when the explosion, there was no proof that it was).
Only one unreciprocated question remains: was there ammunition or any military instrumentation at the Kredmash plant? The Ministry of Defense of Russia declared this while not providing any proof. The authorities of the state and therefore the management of the plant deny any military activity at the enterprise. At a similar time, no traces of ammunition at the plant were detected within the reports of native journalists (the shooting was allotted virtually every day when the strike).
Why the Ministry of Defense of Russia hardly “intentionally” tried to urge into the shopping mall
Based on what was found at the location of the explosions, it’s tough to conclude that there was a “deliberate attack” on the mall. The missile failed to hit Amstor directly. the foremost thronged a part of the shopping mall – the Silpo grocery store, in keeping with the center’s workers, was virtually not livid within the 1st minutes when the explosion (but then it had been conjointly destroyed by fire). Formally, the explosions of each missile transpire on the territory of a neighboring plant – however, one in every one of them fell within the immediate neighborhood of Amstor. it’s logical to assume that the plant was the target of each strike.
The rest is explained by the characteristics of the missiles accustomed to strike (if we have a tendency to settle for the version of the Ukrainian authorities that these were Kh-22 missiles). the very fact is that these missiles aren’t designed for correct attacks on ground targets like “buildings”. They were developed within the Nineteen Sixties (and progressive within the 1970s) for a slender niche of application – assaultive massive teams of ships and international organization craft carriers.
Missiles have 2 complementary steering methods:
After modernization, most of the flight, the rocket was radio-controlled mistreatment AN mechanical phenomenon system: 1st, the precise position of the carrier craft at launch (a indicator within the coordinate system) make up my mind, so a special system counted all changes within the position of the rocket because it affected off from this indicator – altitude, heading, still as drift angles thanks to wind. With these calculations, errors inevitably accumulate, that forestall the missile from being delivered to the target accurately enough to destroy even an oversized ship. The circular probable deviation from the target once mistreatment the Kh-22 solely with AN mechanical phenomenon system is, in keeping with open knowledge, regarding five hundred meters.
In order for the missile to hit the war vessel (having already approached it), and orienting head with a measuring instrument indication was ab initio placed in it: it itself geared toward the ship with the best reflectivity. thanks to the low accuracy of the mechanical phenomenon system throughout the late land, targets of the “group of ships” sort (or one ship in conditions of radio interference that interfered with measuring instrument guidance) were speculated to be attacked solely with nuclear weapons with a capability of 1 megaton.
It is clear that the measuring instrument system isn’t appropriate for assaultive a target of the “factory shop” sort, and thus the missile is employed solely within the “area target” attack mode, however with a “normal” high-explosive fragmentation explosive. With low accuracy, it will hit targets with an awfully massive mass of the explosive – regarding 900 kilograms, which is sort of double the maximum amount because of the operational-tactical and cruise missiles Iskander and Caliber, that Russia uses during this war. The Kh-32 missile, which ought to replace the Kh-22 within the troops, conjointly has virtually [*fr1] the mass of the explosive (in addition, it ought to be rather more accurate). The X-32 has AN measuring device correction system that permits you to search out references on the bottom throughout the flight.
The main advantage of the Kh-22 over different missiles is that plenty of them was made. So, solely state, having abandoned nuclear warheads and every one missile capable of carrying them, two-handed over virtually four hundred Kh-22s to Russia. it’s not famous what number of them remained within the warehouses of the Russian army (some were disposed of in recent decades), however, it’s clear that the Russian army will attack them for months – and can progressively} do thus because the arsenals of more trendy missiles area unit depleted.
Is it attainable to hit such inaccurate, however powerful missiles at objects set within the city?
It is proscribed. during this case, there are unit signs of a crime – one in every of the numerous committed by Russia throughout the invasion of the state.
